Tuning your instrument: ear or tuner, what's the best choice?
Tuning an instrument is a must for all musicians. Some still do it by ear, relying on their listening skills. Others prefer to use tuners (pliers, apps or connected tuners). Both methods coexist in today's musical practice, and each has its advantages. So, should you still learn to tune your instrument by ear, or let technology be your guide?
L'chord à l'oreille: a know-how that has shaped generations of musicians
Before the democratization of electronic tuners, tuning an instrument was done by ear alone. This habit marked generations of musicians. Violinists would take out their tuning fork to adjust their strings, guitarists would ask a friend to give them an A, pianists would line up on the best-tuned instrument in the room. It was a ritual, sometimes tedious, but part of the learning process.
Why tune your instrument by ear?
Tuning by ear requires concentration and experience. The musician must be able to recognize whether a note is too high or too low, and then gradually correct it. Tuning by ear :
develop relative hearing: the ability to identify intervalstone, tone, fifth...),
learns to spot micro height shifts,
stimulates the absolute ear, which enables direct recognition of a note without reference.
This skill is particularly valuable in chamber music, choirs and orchestras, where you have to tune not only with yourself, but also with others. Jazz and classical musicians attach great importance to this: an orchestra doesn't tune to a tuner, but to the oboe, and a jazz quartet adjusts its tuning according to the common color it wants to create.
More than just being in tune, tuning by ear creates a kind of intimate bond with the instrument. You learn to recognize its sound, to feel its vibrations and variations according to humidity, temperature or string wear. For a musician, it's a way of better understanding his or her playing tool and adapting to it in real time.
💡 Tip: to practice, start by comparing two strings that should form a fifth (e.g. A-Mi on a guitar). The beating sound you hear (that little "wah-wah" that vibrates) disappears when the interval is perfectly right.
Real limits in today's practice
This learning process, however instructive, is not easy. Beginners often feel lost: it's hard to know whether the note is slightly too low or too high. The process can quickly become frustrating and discouraging. Even for the most experienced, tuning by ear is not always appropriate. On a noisy stage, in a room full of reverberations or during a fast rehearsal, precision becomes complicated to achieve.
Practices that vary according to musical universe
There is also a difference between musical universes, across generations. Classical and jazz musicians are steeped in the tradition ofchord by ear, because it's part of our collective culture. Conversely, in contemporary music, where many musicians are self-taught, the use of a tuner comes more naturally. The priority is not to develop the relative ear, but to quickly obtain reliable tuning, whether for rehearsing, recording or performing on stage.
New tools for tuning your instrument
Today, there are few musicians who don't own a tuner. In the guitar case, in the pocket or directly on the phone, it has become the number one ally for saving time and avoiding unpleasant surprises. If the ear requires concentration and experience, tuners provide reliability and speed.
Clip-on tuners: small but sturdy
The most widely used is undoubtedly the clip-on tuner. Small and discreet, it attaches directly to the instrument's headstock in a matter of seconds and picks up its vibrations. The result: no need to strain your ears, the tuner works even in the middle of a concert or noisy rehearsal room. The clip-on tuner picks up vibrations directly in the wood, so there's no sound interference. Handy as they are, these little pliers are easy to lose... which is why guitarists collect them.
💡 Tip: always keep a clip-on tuner attached to your instrument: even when switched off, it becomes a little "reminder" to regularly check your tuning.
Mobile applications: the pocket tuner
Then there are the mobile applications(GuitarTuna, n-Track Tuner, Cleartune...). Simply pull out your phone, launch the app and play a note for immediate visual feedback. Simple, free or almost free, they make tuning accessible to everyone, even beginners who don't yet know how to recognize a string that's too tight. Some go a step further, offering alternative tunings that are very popular with folk and rock guitarists.
Often accompanied by a built-in metronome, tuning apps are very handy for rehearsals. On the other hand, the smartphone's microphone picks up everything, including extraneous noise. They are therefore more suited to use in a quiet space.
Intelligent tuners: the new generation
And then there's the new generation: so-called "intelligent" tuners. Some models, like the Roadie Tuner, go so far as to turn the tuning machines for the musician. Others give luminous or vibrating indications to guide the hand. It's bluffing fast, especially when you have to tune several instruments in a row. But these tools raise a question: if the machine does everything, what happens to the ear? Many teachers recommend using them, but not overusing them, to prevent tuning from becoming a mere technical formality. They are still an enormous time-saver, especially when you have to tune several instruments in a row.
In the space of a few years, these tools have totally changed our habits. Tuning by ear used to take several minutes, sometimes longer for a beginner. With a tuner, it's done in seconds. In the context of a concert or studio session, this time-saving makes all the difference. But their success is also due to the peace of mind they bring: knowing you're playing in tune, with no questions asked, is liberating.
💡 Did you know?
Before apps and electronic tuners, the universal reference was the the tuning fork. This small, fork-shaped metal tool vibrates to give the famous A 440 Hz, the world reference for tuning instruments.
Still used in orchestras and conservatories, it remains a symbol of accuracy and tradition. Minimalist and indestructible, it forces the musician to stretch his ears and develop his listening skills.
Tuning your instrument: when and for whom, using which method?
Do you have to choose between an earchord and an electronic tuner? Not really. The two approaches complement each other, and most musicians end up juggling them depending on the context.
For beginners
A tuner is almost indispensable. It avoids the frustration of randomly turning the keys, and allows you to play in tune from the very first notes. But that's no reason to ignore the ear: getting into the habit of listening, even if thechord isn't perfect at first, helps you progress. The best method would be to tune with the tuner, then check one or two strings "the old-fashioned way", comparing sounds.
For intermediate musicians
At this stage, combining the two becomes natural. You can use the tuner to lay a solid foundation, then fine-tune by ear. This is particularly useful in rehearsals and bands, where collective tuning takes precedence over mathematical precision. Many guitarists, for example, set their strings on the tuner before a concert, then quickly adjust by ear to "stick" to the color of the band.
For professionals
The pros know that technology saves time, but it's no substitute for listening. In the studio, a tuner is an indispensable insurance policy: a failed recording due to a wrong string is costly. On stage, it allows you to retune in a matter of seconds between two pieces. But in an orchestra, a choir or a quartet, it's always the ear that has the last word: we align ourselves with the other musicians, with the acoustics of the room, sometimes even with the mood of the piece.
☺️ Newzik's tips for tuning your instrument :
In rehearsal: start with a tuner, then play a few intervals by ear to train your listening skills.
In concert: always keep a tuner close at hand, but fine-tune by ear just before starting a piece.
Solo at home: regularly try to tune by ear only, then check with a tuner. It's a stress-free way to make progress.
Practical guide: tuning your instrument at home
Guitar
This is the instrument where tuning comes up most often, as the strings quickly go out of tune.
With a tuner: a clip-on model is the simplest. Simply scratch a string and follow the needle (or display) until the note is right.
By ear: start by tuning the A string (often with a tuning fork or an appliance), then use it as a reference to adjust the other strings by intervals (low E → A, D → G, etc.).
Tuto: easy guitar tuning for beginners
Violin
The violin requires more finesse, as accuracy is down to the millimetre on the pegs.
With a tuner: start with the A string (440 Hz), then tune the others in fifths.
By ear: listen for the "beats" between two adjacent strings. When the vibrations disappear, the fifth is right.
Tuto: tune your violin quickly and easily
💡 Tip : use the thin turnbuckles (at the tailpiece) to adjust more easily, especially if you're just starting out.
Piano
A piano can rarely be tuned on its own: it's advisable to call in a professional, as it's a complex job. Not only do you have to tune each string, but you also have to manage the equality between several strings per note, and slightly adapt the tuning according to registers (this is called "equal temperament"). You can quickly check your chord with an app or tuner, but don't try to do it yourself without training.
FAQ: everything you need to know about instrument tuning
How to tune your instrument without a tuner?
You can use a tuning fork, a reference note (A on the piano, for example), or a string that's already in tune. The idea is to compare sounds and adjust until they "harmonize". It takes longer, but it develops your ear and precision.
Is it really worth learning to tune by ear?
Yes, even if you use a tuner on a daily basis. The ear allows you to adjust in a group, to react to variations in acoustics or to neighboring instruments. A tuner gives the exact note, but it doesn't replace the ability to listen and adapt.
What's the best type of tuner?
It depends on the context. The clip-on tuner is handy on stage because it picks up vibrations and ignores ambient noise. Smartphone apps are perfect for troubleshooting at home. Smart" and connected tuners offer greater convenience, but are not indispensable.
How long does it take to tune your instrument?
By ear, it takes two to three minutes for an experienced musician, more for a beginner. With a tuner, it's done in seconds. That's why most musicians prefer the digital tool for concerts and rehearsals.
Can you tune an instrument using a telephone?
Yes, there are many free and paid apps (such as GuitarTuna, Pano Tuner, n-Track Tuner...) that turn a smartphone into a tuner. Their accuracy depends on the phone's microphone and the sound environment, but for everyday use or solo, they work very well.
What are the best online tuners?
Musicca (multi-instrument, simple and visual)
iMusic-School (ad-free, various instruments + integrated keyboard)
Tuner-Online.com (guitar-focused, fast and reliable)
OnlineTuner.org (advanced configuration options)
Do professional musicians use electronic tuners?
Absolutely. In the studio or on stage, speed and reliability are paramount. Many pros start with a tuner, then adjust by ear to find the band's color and coherence. One doesn't replace the other, they complement each other.
Can I tune my piano myself using an online tuner?
In theory, yes. In practice, no: tuning a piano is a profession. Each note is made up of several strings, which must be adjusted in relation to each other with calculated micro-gaps (the famous "equal temperament"). An app can tell you if the A is right, but it doesn't replace the expertise of a technician.
What are the most common mistakes to avoid when tuning up?
Turn the wheel too quickly, at the risk of breaking a rope.
Relying solely on the screen of a tuner without listening to the actual sound.
Neglect external conditions: heat, humidity or stage lighting can take an instrument out of tune in a matter of minutes.
For new strings: don't "pull" them gently to stabilize them, which leads to almost immediate detuning after installation.
♫ ou're a violinist, guitarist or pianist? Discover Newzik. The app that brings your scores together, making them easy to annotate, organize and share. Alone, in rehearsal or in concert, everything is designed to simplify your daily life and give you the freedom to play.
